While I do realize that I have been writing about the midterm elections pretty much nonstop since the big blue wave crashed upon the shores of American politics — and that there are plenty of other things going on that I should be writing about — I still have to indulge my inner glee just one more time today. Tomorrow I’ll tackle some stuff looking in a more forward direction, I promise….
We are currently in the lame duck session of Congress, which will last right up until the beginning of January. But there are two important footnotes to consider when pondering what the outgoing Republican Congress might get up to in the meantime and what the makeup of the next Senate will be. One of these is from Ohio, and the other is from Minnesota.
Ohio’s Senate election this year was actually a special election. This was the seat that JD Vance held up until he became vice president. Two years ago, the Republican governor replaced Vance with another Republican, but only until a special election could be held. Senator Jon Husted was just defeated by Sherrod Brown — who won’t have to wait until January to take his seat. By state law, the longest Husted can remain in his seat is up until December 15th (and feel free to insert your own “Jon Husted’s ass…” joke here, about him leaving). After he steps down, Brown will be sworn into office, reducing the Republican majority from 53-47 down to 52-48. This could be important in any last-minute budget negotiations right before the Senate breaks for the holidays.
The other curveball in all of this will only really have an impact on whether Chuck Schumer becomes majority leader or not in the new Senate. Because Senator Amy Klobuchar won her race to become Minnesota’s governor. This means when she takes office, she will have to resign her Senate seat and name her own successor (to fill out her term). This won’t affect the balance of power in the Senate in the least, but by party rules it will affect the vote for who will become minority leader.
There will be 56 incoming Democratic senators next year. Either Schumer or Chris Van Hollen will have to get the votes of over half of them to win the leadership battle. You’d think this would mean they’d need 29 votes (half plus one), but in fact they will only need 28 votes, because only 55 of them will be voting. The only Democrats allowed to vote are those who will be serving next year, and Klobuchar won’t be one of them (so she won’t get a vote). She won’t be sworn in as governor until after the leadership election takes place. In other words, her replacement won’t get a vote either.
Both of these changes are a little esoteric, but they do change the math a bit. But there’s one more thing worth saying about that last one — call it a footnote to the footnote, if you will. And I admit that it’s a little controversial, but I just have to toss the idea out there nonetheless.
After Klobuchar names her Senate successor, they will hold the office for less than a year before a special election lets Minnesota voters have a say in who will fill out the remainder of Klobuchar’s term. So next November, the seat will be up for a vote, and whichever candidate wins will serve until the 2030 election allows voters to choose who gets the seat for a full six-year term.
Klobuchar can name anyone she pleases, of course. Current Governor Tim Walz has been proposed, but he responded to the idea by saying he’d rather “eat glass” than fill the Senate seat himself. Which, you’ve got to admit, sounds pretty definitive.
Normally, in this situation, a governor has two basic choices. The first would be to name an up-and-coming politician from their own party to fill the seat, in the hopes that they’ll be approved by the voters to fill out the rest of the term. The second is to choose a placeholder — a politician who commits to not running for the seat in the next election, just to act as a safe vote in the meantime (which will then give the voters an open choice, rather than an “incumbent-versus-challenger” election).
I have no idea what Klobuchar will do, but I do know what I’d like to see happen. I’d like to see Klobuchar choose that second route and name Al Franken to fill her Senate seat until the special election next November.
Franken, of course, was a senator from Minnesota. He was elected in 2008 (in an election so close it took months for him to actually be seated, while the court case played out) and he served until 2018. He stepped down during the height of the “#MeToo” era, after a photograph and an accusation of impropriety by a comedienne who had spent time with Franken on a U.S.O. tour. This was then followed by further accusations from women who had posed for photographs with Franken. The worst accusation was that he kissed one woman on the cheek without her consent and attempted to kiss another without her consent, or that Franken got a little handsy during photos with them. Today, in the Trump era, there is a whole different standard for sexual misconduct of any type, but back then it was the peak of the “cancel culture” era, and Franken was forced to resign his Senate seat.
I thought this was a shame, because Franken was such an excellent senator. For his first term in office, he was intentionally subdued and stuck his nose to the grindstone to convince the voters of Minnesota that they hadn’t made a mistake in electing a comedian to high office. In his second term (after getting easily re-elected) he was beginning to loosen up a bit and allow his wry personality to show through, especially in committee hearings while grilling witnesses. In addition, he was one of the most impressive voices speaking out against Trump, up until he resigned. He could step right back into that role now, which would provide an additional Democratic foil to Trump and his entire administration.
Would the women of Minnesota accept Franken as a placeholder senator for most of 2027? I don’t know the answer to that. Would Democrats nationwide support Franken, or would he still be seen as unfit for office? After Trump changed all the rules in this regard, it is hard to say. I also have no idea what Klobuchar thinks of Franken — what the chances are that she’d even be open to such a suggestion. It would be a solid statement of support if Klobuchar — a woman senator/governor — became the one to (temporarily) give Franken his job back, that’s for sure. But maybe Klobuchar doesn’t think he deserves it.
It seems pretty certain that Franken would accept the position with the caveat that he not run for re-election. Serving for just one more year would be the capstone of his political career, and it’d be a much better way for him to exit the political stage. It would also likely be more acceptable if everyone knew it was just for a short “placeholder” period. So I am tossing the idea out there for consideration. Because I for one would love to see Senator Al Franken grilling various Trump minions in Senate committees for the next year — it would be not only sharp and intelligent questioning, but also wryly hilarious (in Franken’s signature style).
[Full Disclosure: While Al Franken was serving as senator, I and my wife had the chance to meet him backstage at a Netroots convention (in the green room, before he gave a speech). We posed for photos with him. And yeah, he did put an arm around both of us for the picture. But my wife reports that he did not do anything inappropriate at all during this photo op. That’s just our personal experience, for whatever it is worth.]
— Chris Weigant
Follow Chris on Twitter: @ChrisWeigant
I second that motion.
i know it’s a bit insane, but personally I’d like to see her appoint Renee Good’s spouse Becca. it’s only a year, and I’d like to see the ice agents who did Renee in have to face her grieving widow with the force of law behind her.